Are you about to start driving lessons? Then the question of whether to choose an automatic or a shift car soon arises. That choice determines not only how you learn to drive, but also what you will soon be allowed to do with your license. In this article, we explain the differences, discuss the pros and cons, and give you tips for making the right choice.
What is the difference between automatic and shift driving lessons?
When you take driving lessons in an automatic, you learn to drive without shifting gears. The car does this itself. You have no clutch pedal and don't have to think about the right gear.
With a switch car, on the contrary, you learn to shift gears. You work with a clutch pedal, have to learn to drive off without the engine stalling, shift up and down and, for example, perform incline tests with the clutch.
Important to know: If you pass in an automatic, you get a driver's license with code 78. This allows you to drive only automatic cars. If you pass in a shift car, you may drive both types of cars.
What are the benefits of automatic driving lessons?
Learning to drive faster
You don't have to learn to shift gears, allowing you to fully focus on traffic. As a result, you often get your license faster.
Less stress
No engine stalling at traffic lights, no hassle with ramp tests and less chance of panic moments. Especially nice for people with fear of failure or driving anxiety.
Outlook for the future
Electric driving is on the rise, and almost all electric cars are automatics. So the chances of you driving an automatic later are high.
What are the disadvantages of automatic driving lessons?
Limited driving license
An automatic license does not allow you to drive a shift car. If you want to do that later, you will have to take the test again in a shift car.
Reduced availability of teaching cars and instructors
Not every driving school offers automatic driving lessons. Some driving schools, such as Driving School Zero from Oostzaan, does offer it, other driving schools again do not. As a result, the waiting time may be longer or the price may be slightly higher.
What are the advantages of driving lessons in a shift car?
Full driving privileges
With a shift driving license, you can drive both types of cars. More freedom now and in the future.
Useful abroad or for loaner cars
Switch cars are still the norm in some countries (and in many rental cars). Then it is convenient if you can drive both types.
What are the disadvantages of driving lessons in a shift car?
Longer learning curve
Learning to shift gears takes practice. It causes some novice drivers frustration or uncertainty at first.
More distractions in the beginning
Because you have to think about clutching, shifting and revving, it can be harder to focus on traffic.
For whom is automatic driving lessons a smart choice?
- If you want to get your driver's license quickly and without hassle
- If you suffer from driving or fear of failure
- If you are sure you will soon be driving an automatic (e.g., electric car)
- If you have difficulty with motor skills or coordination
For others, it may be wiser to take the extra effort of a switch car for granted, in exchange for more long-term flexibility.
What do you choose?
The choice between automatic or shift car is personal. Do you want your license quickly and expect to drive an automatic in the future? Then automatic driving lessons are an excellent choice. Do you want maximum freedom, even if you ever need to drive another car? Then a shift driving license is the safest route.
Whatever you choose, the most important thing is that you feel comfortable with your instructor and that you can learn the driving at your pace. Therefore, it is always advisable to book a test lesson. If you're unsure between a shift car and an automatic, it may also pay to take a trial lesson in an automatic and a trial lesson in a switch car. That way you will experience what you like best.
English 
Dutch 
French 
German 